Genres
A genre is a label for reader expectations.
Ideally, there would be a single set of genres that everyone can agree upon. Since genres often blur together, it’s difficult to get agreement. One bookstore groups Mystery and Crime together while another bundles Mystery and Thriller.
Some genres describe the plot. A romance describes how a couple’s relationship grows over time. A crime story describes a crime and the efforts of law enforcement to bring them to justice.
What is the plot of a comedy? Or a science fiction story? Those genres don’t have plot expectations like other genres. That’s led me to the conclusion that different genres address different reader expectations. And therefore, I believe all stories have multiple genres.
Plot Genres
Romance | Mystery | Crime | Thriller | Action | Survival | War… etc.
Plot Genres include expected plot beats and characters. A romance has lovers whose relationship grows; action has heroes who fight villains; soldiers who go to battle. Plot genres can be combined. For example, a cop might be investigating a murder (mystery/crime) and suspects a killer who kills on every full moon. They have to stop the killer from killing again (thriller).
Setting / Premise Genres
Science Fiction | Fantasy | Historical | Contemporary | Alternative History
The Setting genre doesn’t include any expected plot beats or characters. Instead, it focusses on the world or universe in which the story takes place. Settings often place constraints on the story. For example, a “historical fiction” story tells us nothing about the plot, only that it takes place in a different time than ours. A historical romance tells us what happens (a couple’s relationship evolves), but does it happen in Victorian England? In occupied Poland during WW2? In Ancient Greece? Each of these settings contains different societal norms, and cultural expectations for how men and women interact.
Any story not set in contemporary times will contain elements unfamiliar to most readers. Consequently, the story may requires significant worldbuilding to explain how that world works. Advanced technology and scientific breakthroughs are common in science fiction; fantasies may contain magic systems or fantastical creatures, and historical settings may contain customs and societies that are different from our own.
Emotional Tone Genre
Horror | Suspense | Dramatic | Comedy
The Emotional Genre asks the question: what do you want the reader to feel for most of the story? Horror stories aim to frighten the reader; suspenseful stories try to keep the reader on the edge of their seat, turning pages to satisfy their anticipation. Comedic stories are light-hearted, keeping the story from becoming too weighty. Dramatic stories offer a level or seriousness and formality.
Audience Genre</span
Children | Middle Grade (ages ~8-14) | Young Adult (ages ~12-18) | New Adult (ages ~18-30) | Adult | Gender
Who is your audience?
A story appropriate to one age range may not be appropriate for another.
Children’s books tend to have simpler themes and vocabulary (no cussing!). The characters tend to be similar age to the readers. Violence and mature themes are absent in stories for younger readers.
Mixing Genres
I believe each story has multiple genres, at least one from each “layer.”
Some examples:
Die Hard: Action/Thriller, Contemporary, Dramatic, Adult
Clue: Mystery, Contemporary, Comedy, Adult (Note: Clue was released in 1985 and set in 1954, so it wasn’t old enough to be considered historical)
You’ve Got Mail: Romance, Contemporary, Comedy, Adult
